✓ 24/7 Expert Customer Support
✓ Lifetime Warranty + Easy Returns
✓ Best Pricing on Diamonds & Jewelry

James Allen True Hearts Vs Whiteflash A Cut Above (2024)

Looking to know which is better between James Allen True Hearts Vs Whiteflash A Cut Above?

You’re at the right place!

This is our comparison of the James Allen True Hearts Vs Whiteflash A Cut Above.

In this article, I have reviewed both the cuts in-depth and will fully explain to you which one is better.

Let’s get started with an in-depth look at what sets these cuts apart.

James Allen True Heart

True Hearts is a high-end collection of flawless diamonds. A True Heart diamond has the trademark of the most ideal cut round diamonds with flawless internal symmetry and proportions, as well as exceptional gem grading for cut and polish.

True heart diamonds have a beautiful heart and arrow design. When seen from the bottom, these diamonds display a very symmetrical 8 heart design. The eight arrows are visible from above.

This beautiful design is extremely difficult to come by. In reality, True Heart diamonds account for less than 1% of all diamonds in the world. True Hearts is only available in round, princess, or cushion cut diamonds since the Hearts and Arrows design is only found in these forms.

Whiteflash A Cut Above

Whiteflash Diamonds is a well-known diamond store on the internet. Kiplinger’s Personal Finance named the firm “Lord of the Online Rings,” and it has a vast assortment of diamond rings in store. 

Whiteflash is an AGS-certified diamond dealer and is a member of the American Gem Society. Their trendy wedding jewelry and elegant engagement rings are their most well-known products.

The headquarters of Whiteflash Diamonds are in Houston, Texas. Whiteflash is one of the early pioneers of the internet diamond market, having been founded in 2000. 

The company’s A Cut Above collection of high-quality diamonds is well-known. Since 2004, Whiteflash has gotten high marks from the Better Business Bureau on a yearly basis.

James Allen and the True Hearts Collection

In their True Hearts line, James Allen promises a “good assortment of Ideal Cuts,” calling them “the ultimate expression of love.” The phrase fits with their broader marketing strategy, which focuses on the emotional experience of diamond shopping.


True Hearts Diamond

On the James Allen website, it’s difficult to locate any True Hearts diamond parameters.

Although the term implies an Ideal Cut, which is a minimum prerequisite for Hearts and Arrows optical symmetry, an Ideal Cut does not necessarily result in a real Hearts and Arrows diamond.

The shift from Ideal Cut to True Hearts is a bit of a hazy area due to a lack of formal data and specified proportions.

What James Allen does give, however, are guarantees of a masterpiece:

”At James Allen, we take pride in presenting only the finest Hearts and Arrows diamonds money can buy – every single True Hearts diamond we sell is cut and polished at 100X magnification.

Furthermore, our exclusive Diamond Display Technology lets you see any True Hearts diamond magnified in 360° so you can see exactly what you are getting.’’

A Cut Above by Whiteflash

Whiteflash’s A Cut Above line is built on painstakingly made diamonds with great cut precision, resulting in spectacular light performance.

Whiteflash’s A Cut Above line includes world-class Hearts and Arrows diamonds. To maintain the standard of a real H&A diamond, each diamond is subjected to a thorough examination.

When seen from the tip, the A Cut Above diamonds display an incredibly symmetrical 8 hearts design, much like any other normal H&A diamond. From above, a dazzling internal reflection of eight arrows may be observed.

The American Gem Society labs examine the A Cut Above diamonds, and only the best are awarded the Triple Ideal Status, which qualifies them for the A Cut Above designation.

Whiteflash Diamonds’ goods are of the highest possible quality. The American Gem Society certifies all diamonds, and Whiteflash’s A Cut Above diamonds are noted for their exceptional cut and quality.

They include a contemporary wedding collection as well as exquisite engagement rings.


True Hearts Certification 

The most famous diamond grading laboratories, AGS and GIA, have certified all True Hearts diamonds. These accounts, on the other hand, make no mention of the diamonds being True Hearts.

At most, the AGS certificate rates the diamond as an excellent cut. Similarly, the True Hearts is rated as an Excellent Cut diamond by the GIA.

 However, if you examine the diamond’s symmetry ratios, polish, and proportions, you’ll notice that True Hearts outperform normal superb or perfect cut diamonds.

Whiteflash Certification

When seen from the tip, the A Cut Above diamonds display an incredibly symmetrical 8 hearts design, much like any other normal H&A diamond. From above, a dazzling internal reflection of eight arrows may be observed.

The American Gem Society labs examine the A Cut Above diamonds, and only the best are awarded the Triple Ideal Status, which qualifies them for the A Cut Above designation.

Whiteflash conducts stringent tests like as the Ideal Scope, ASET Scope, and Hearts and Arrows Scope to complete the examination and ensure that only the most perfect diamonds reach their consumers.

If you’d like to learn more about how A Cut Above diamonds are evaluated. 


When searching for something as significant as an engagement or wedding ring, quality is paramount; you’ll want something that will last a lifetime.

James Allen True Heart

True Hearts by James Allen are among the finest diamonds available. They have incredible brightness, glitter, and fire, and they appear absolutely stunning. They do, however, come with a price tag to match, so keep that in mind while planning your budget.

 You won’t have to worry about the authenticity of their diamonds because the majority of them are IGI and GIA certified.

Furthermore, James Allen’s products come with a lifetime warranty, so you don’t have to worry about the quality. This means you may have your diamonds fixed or serviced at no charge at any time.

A Cut Above Whiteflash

All of these exceptional precision cut diamonds are in stock and ready to ship. They’ve been extensively examined in the lab and by Whiteflash’s team of gemologists.

They are given a full bundle of superior light performance photographs, as well as the industry’s top assurance policies and perks.

A Cut Above and other high-end diamond brands come with branded lab results. This is the most effective technique to link the diamond to a set of brand-specific criteria and requirements. 

One advantage for the consumer is that in the case of a loss, the insurance claim replacement must meet all of the brand’s advertised specifications.


So now we’ve reached the most thrilling part of the story. Price is a big concern no matter what you’re buying. Let’s see who can provide a more reasonable price between the two.

James Allen True Heart

Despite the fact that James Allen is a household brand, their pricing continues to astound me. The diamond that costs $5000 at luxury companies like Tiffany can be had for roughly $3000 from James Allen, sans the famous name and the praised blue box, of course.

Take a look at some of their stunning jewelry, as well as their costs. I don’t know about you, but I adore side stone settings in the diamonds, so I went to James Allen and looked through this section. 

A Cut Above Whiteflash

According to my general analysis of the pricing of various diamonds, I discovered that A Cut Above diamonds at Whiteflash are more expensive than James Allen True Hearts. Furthermore, as you look at greater carat diamonds, the price gap continues to grow.


To summarize, both James Allen and Whiteflash’s True Hearts Diamonds are bright and of the highest quality. Both have their diamonds confirmed by AGS and GIA, two of the most reputable gem grading laboratories in the world.

So I can’t really pick one as the finest; but, if you have the funds, I’d recommend going for these exceptional and rare James Allen True Hearts Diamond.


Scroll to Top
Secured By miniOrange