✓ 24/7 Expert Customer Support
✓ Lifetime Warranty + Easy Returns
✓ Best Pricing on Diamonds & Jewelry

James Allen vs Costco: Which Is Better? (2024 Comparison)

Looking to know which is better between James Allen vs Costco?

You’re at the right place!

This is our comparison of the James Allen vs Costco.

In this article, I have reviewed both the brands in-depth and will fully explain to you which one is better.

Let’s get started with an in-depth look at what sets these brands apart.

1) History

James Allen

James Allen Schultz and his wife Michele launched Jamesallen.com in 1998. It’s easy to toss out a year like 1998 without considering what it implies, but when you think about it, 1998 was a long time ago in Internet years.

James Allen was founded as a result of its founder’s dissatisfaction with his own hunt for an engagement ring. The business flourished swiftly after its introduction in 1998, soon establishing itself as one of the leading online engagement ring merchants.

They rebuilt their website as JamesAllen.com in 2005. They began to take their engagement ring line extremely seriously at this time.

They’ve also started collaborating with well-known designers in order to provide you something truly unique.

James Allen proceeded to change the way people shop for diamond rings online. As a result, not only do consumers have better trust in their purchases, but the rest of the business is compelled to follow suit.


Costco, full name Costco Wholesale Corporation, is an American retailer of warehouse clubs and wholesale clubs, which sell large amounts of items at significantly discounted prices to club members who pay an annual membership fee. It is one among the world’s largest merchants. Issaquah, Washington is the home of Costco.

Costco began in 1976 in San Diego, when Sol Price, a pioneer in warehouse club retailing, founded the first Price Club. Costco was founded in 1983 by Jeffrey H. Brotman and James D. Sinegal in Seattle.

The company’s name was changed to Costco Companies, Inc. in 1997, and the current name was chosen in 1999. The corporation had outlets across the United States, Canada, Mexico, Europe, the Far East, and Australia in the early twenty-first century.

2) Website Navigation

James Allen

James Allen’s website has a sleek and contemporary style to it, which I enjoy. The main page includes everything a consumer needs to get their attention.

Furthermore, they offer the correct kind of filters, which makes looking for rings a breeze. You may shop for rings based on metal type or ring style. Choose from a variety of customer-inspired rings or design your own. With just a few clicks, you may sort the diamonds by cut, clarity, color, and carat weight.

The website of James Allen is quite nicely designed, and you can quickly navigate through all of the pages, whether it is the main page or various sorts of jewelry and diamonds sites it also feels like a premium feel to it

I found it very easy to navigate to James Allen’s website. All the necessary information is nearly arranged and are easily accessible. Categories such as Fine jewelry, Weddings collection and Designer Collection are all easy to access it helps to save time.


You must be a member to shop at a Costco warehouse. However, you may shop at Costco without being a member if you shop online. Unfortunately, if you aren’t a member, your purchases will be subject to a 5% fee.

If you’re a Costco member, you may have your diamond rings delivered to a Costco location; otherwise, you’ll have to wait two to three days for delivery. While I can’t discover much details on in-store buying, the internet shopping experience is simple and uncomplicated.

Winner: Hands down James Allen is the winner.

3) Quality

James Allen

James Allen never fails to deliver high-quality, precisely designed rings with diamonds, in my opinion. Their rings are skillfully created to perfection with the expertise of skilled gemologists.

Before you receive your ring, it goes through a thorough testing procedure to ensure that it is the ideal fit for you. James Allen provides conflict-free diamonds as well as authenticity certificates. You won’t have to worry about the authenticity of their diamonds because the majority of them are IGI and GIA certified.

Furthermore, James Allen’s products come with a lifetime warranty, so you don’t have to worry about the quality. This means you may have your rings fixed or serviced at no charge at any time.


All diamonds sold by Costco are guaranteed to be VS2 clarity and I colour or greater. The bulk of their diamonds, according to our analysis, fall into these classes. The diamond is almost certainly eye-clean. Although the diamond’s hue is near-colorless, it will seem white.

These grades result in a good-value diamond, one that is less expensive yet still seems perfect to the human eye. However, the reduced grading is the issue. The most crucial component is the diamond cut. It’s what gives the diamond its radiance.

Because Costco does not give a cut grade for all of its diamonds, it’s difficult to evaluate whether or not they’re of excellent quality. And don’t expect to find premium, really high-quality diamonds at Costco.

If you’re searching for low prices and in-person shopping, Costco is a wonderful option. Costco diamonds are generally of good quality and offer good value, as long as they are GIA certified. You may get a ring for half the price of other big-name jewelry boutiques.

Winner: In terms of quality James Allen is the clear winner.

4) Store Location

James Allen

James Allen is located in the United States and does the majority of its business online. If you live in Washington or New York, though, you’re in luck. You can come to James Allen’s shop for a one-on-one examination of the rings you want.

James Allen maintains a store in the Georgetown neighborhood of Washington, D.C., as well as a showroom on Fifth Avenue in New York City. All of their things may be sent anywhere in the world.


The headquarters of Costco are in Washington, D.C. Costco has 828 warehouses globally as of March 2022, with 572 in the United States. Costco is constantly expanding its footprint.

Costco also offers an online purchasing experience that is simple and quick.

Winner: Costco wins this round because of its larger network of stores.

5) Pricing

James Allen

James Allen is a brand for everyone. And it more than lives up to its billing. At James Allen, diamonds and other jewels are reasonably priced.

However, cheaper pricing does not imply a reduction in quality. That isn’t true at all. The quality is precisely what you’d expect for the price. They have diamonds of different shapes and sizes. For example, these gems at James Allen are worth serious consideration.

You may acquire some really substandard pieces from them, as well as some extremely fine and expensive gems that are well worth the money. The pricing are reasonable, and the ability to create your ring from beginning to end gives you greater control.


The engagement rings at Costco are all ready-made. There are no customising options at all.

This makes finding the ideal ring difficult. You may adore a ring design, but the diamond isn’t the right size or shape for you. Perhaps a rose gold metal is more your style. Or the ring isn’t the right size for your finger.

To make Costco worthwhile, you must select a ring in your ideal size, shape, and setting while staying within your budget. Yes, Costco offers incredible pricing when compared to traditional brick-and-mortar diamond dealers. Prices can be as low as half of what a comparable ring would cost at a big-box jewellery retailer.

Even while you can save a lot of money by buying an uncertified diamond, we couldn’t really advocate it. It will have to be a personal decision.

If you have the option of purchasing at Costco or at an online merchant like James Allen, we strongly suggest the latter.

Winner: James Allen is worth each penny. 

6) Shipping

James Allen

I’m afraid James Allen promises to give international delivery, but this isn’t the reality. Looking at their list of shipping destinations on their website, I discovered that they only ship to 22 countries, including Spain, the United Kingdom, Sweden, the United Arab Emirates, Australia, Canada, and Germany.

They provide FedEx Priority, FedEx Economy, and USPS shipping options. There are no deliveries to P.O. Box addresses.


Costco provides doorstep delivery in the US. They provide FedEx Priority, FedEx Economy, and USPS shipping options. There are no deliveries to P.O. Box addresses.

Winner: James Allen because James Allen is an online store and all their orders have to be delivered separately and from day one they have been doing an excellent job.

7) Return Policy

James Allen

Customers of James Allen have access to a sound and simple return policy. If you’re not completely satisfied with your item after getting it, you can return it within 30 days, no questions asked.

Additionally, free return shipping is only available for orders placed in the United States and Canada. A $50 return shipping fee will be applied to overseas purchases.


This is one of Costco’s key advantages. Costco is recognised for having a broad return policy, which includes jewellery.

If you don’t like the ring, you may return it to any Costco warehouse within 30 days of purchase, no questions asked.

Winner: Costco wins this round.

8) Customer Support

James Allen

James Allen has a staff of non-commissioned diamond professionals that can assist you make the best decisions regarding your jewelry. Your complaints will be addressed by their professional customer service staff.

You can reach a JA representative at any time of the day or week by dialing 1-877-826-9866. You may contact them by Skype or email at [email protected]. Aside from that, you may contact them directly through their website and schedule a real-time diamond examination.


Costco employees are not trained in the field of jewels. Expect them to be unable to provide expert counsel. It’s essentially a self-serve purchasing experience.

Your local independent jeweler, on the other hand, can sit down with you and assist you evaluate possibilities while also teaching you about diamonds.

Even internet diamond sellers provide greater customer service.

Winner: James Allen takes the win. They have set up an industry standard in customer support.

9) Customer Reviews Online

James Allen

On Wedding Wire, James Allen has a 4.8 star rating based on more than 1000 reviews. Customers at James Allen appear to be pleased with both the service and the price.

There are hundreds of reviews on Wedding Wire that you may read. To be honest, I was pleasantly pleased by James Allen’s consistent reputation across the internet.


For Costco diamonds there are not many rewards to find. Most reviews are bad ones or the customer is not satisfied with the quality of the product.

Winner: James Allen takes a clear win.

10) Warranty

James Allen

James Allen offers a lifetime guarantee on maintenance and repairs. From cleaning to polishing to prong tightening, we’ll take care of any problems you have.

James Allen offers free resizing for the first year following your purchase. James Allen understands how difficult it may be to find the right size. You can trust James Allen to make sure everything is in order.


After you’ve purchased the engagement ring, Costco does not offer resizing or a guarantee. This is a significant disadvantage. 

Winner: All reputable diamond jewelers provide post-purchase guarantees. With this in mind James Allen wins.

Overall Winner

 Costco offers greater diamond grades and lower rates on engagement rings and bridal sets than other major corporate jewellery retailers like Kay, Zales, and Jared.

Costco, on the other hand, pales in comparison to an online diamond shop like James Allen.

Costco does not provide any form of guarantee, however James Allen provides a free warranty that includes normal servicing. You can return the ring at any time, but if it’s been sized or if Costco deems it unreturnable, you’re out of luck.

The expertise that James Allen possesses is the main reason I support him against Costco.

Would you rather buy from a firm with top-of-the-line diamond specialists that can review your picked diamond with you and answer all of your questions than one with customer service that can’t answer your inquiries about buying diamonds?

Because James Allen specialised in diamonds, their workers are also diamond experts. Costco, however, does not.

Costco is not a jewellery store, thus they just do not understand jewellery. Simple as that. Because if they did, they would have the same level of openness as James Allen.

James Allen is clearly a superior site to buy diamond and engagement rings.


James Allen Vs Ritani

Brian Gavin Vs James Allen

Scroll to Top
Secured By miniOrange