✓ 24/7 Expert Customer Support
✓ Lifetime Warranty + Easy Returns
✓ Best Pricing on Diamonds & Jewelry

James Allen True Hearts Vs Ideal Cut: Which Is Better? (2024 Comparison)

Looking to know which is better between James Allen True Hearts Vs Ideal Cut?

You’re at the right place!

This is our comparison of the James Allen True Hearts Vs Ideal Cut.

In this article, I have reviewed both the cuts in-depth and will fully explain to you which one is better.

Let’s get started with an in-depth look at what sets these cuts apart.

What is a True Heart Diamond?

True heart diamonds are a small subset of perfect cut diamonds that have an elaborate design of eight arrows on top and eight hearts on the bottom.

Only around 1% of all ideal cut diamonds have the precise dimensions and internal symmetry that qualify them for the True Hearts award. True heart diamonds are the greatest and rarest diamonds on the market because of this.

The number 8 is similar to the sign of infinity, which represents boundless love. As a result, giving your sweetheart a True Heart diamond may be a wonderful way to convey your unending love.

Because James Allen has trademarked the term “True Heart,” you won’t see a diamond labeled “True Heart” at any other retailer.

However, diamonds with a similar Heart and Arrow design can be found in other stores under a different name. The Astor at Blue Nile and ‘A Cut Above’ at Whiteflash, for example, both include a heart and arrow motif.

The costs at James Allen, on the other hand, are unbeatable.

What is an Ideal Cut Diamond?

The AGS  uses the term “ideal cut” to designate diamonds with the best cutting and the best light performance.

AGS rates diamond quality on a scale of 0 to 10, with 10 denoting “bad” and 0 denoting “perfect.” The lower the AGS grade, the poorer the quality of the diamond.

As a result, perfect cut diamonds will always have an AGS cut grade of 0, indicating that this is the best cut grade that AGS graded diamonds may achieve.

Keep in mind that the phrase “perfect cut” is only used when a diamond has been verified by AGS. On the other hand, the GIA  describes its top-rated diamonds as having “excellent cut.”

The distinction between the two, though, isn’t anything you should be concerned about. The only difference is that AGS divides its top tier into two categories , but GIA combines them into a single category dubbed “excellent cut.”

It’s also worth noting that optimal cut is only possible in round, brilliant, and princess cut diamonds. You won’t be able to locate an Ideal cut diamond with a cushion or Oval cut, and vice versa.

Difference Between James Allen True Heart And Ideal Cut Diamond

A real heart diamond is an ideal cut diamond, however not every ideal cut diamond is a true heart diamond. Only when the classic heart and arrow design is seen from the top and bottom of an Ideal Cut diamond does it become a real heart. 

Ideal cut diamonds are far more common than true heart diamonds. True heart diamonds make up just 1% of ideal cut diamonds, however all True Heart Diamonds are Ideal Cut.

What Are Those Extra Dollars Worth?

I’m going to talk about two really beautiful diamond cuts: Heart and Arrow cut vs Ideal or Excellent cut. We’ll look at which of them is worth the money later in this post.

Is the extra money spent on the heart and arrow cut truly worth it? What’s the difference between these two cuts that makes one preferable than the other? This is a comprehensive guide to all of these issues and more!

A premium collection dedicated to the unusual heart and arrow cut is offered by a select diamond producers. ‘True Hearts’ is the name given to James Allen’s collection of Heart and Arrow Cut diamonds.

Ideal cut diamonds, on the other hand, are frequently utilized as a baseline for grading all other diamonds. The symmetry scores, optimal proportions, and great polish are all characteristics of the ideal cut.

James Allen True Heart

True Heart is James Allen’s premium line, which features ultra perfect diamonds in round, princess, and cushion shapes. While round cut diamonds appear to dominate the selection, there is also a lovely princess cut and cushion cut variety.

Round Cut True Hearts

The round cut ‘Authentic Hearts’ diamonds are true ‘heart and arrow’ diamonds. They have the best proportions and symmetry in the world. Furthermore, the cut and polish of these genuine hearts is flawless.

The interior symmetry of the diamonds is revealed by the round cut real hearts, which are intricately and precisely made. The diamond’s shape and dimensions are overshadowed when viewed from certain angles.

When seen from the top, the diamond has a flawlessly created symmetry that produces arrows. On the contrary, if you look at it from the bottom up, you’ll notice a pattern of hearts. As a result, the cut is known as the ‘Heart and Arrow’ cut.

Well, well, well… Is it simple to get True Heart status?

No, it’s never simple. And it is for this reason that only around 1% of all diamonds earn the distinction of being termed a True Heart. This honor is bestowed only on the most precisely proportioned and internally symmetrical diamonds.

James Allen Ideal Cut

Round, brilliant, princess cut diamonds are ideal cut diamonds. Tolkowsky’s ideal cut is used as a model for today’s ideal cut diamonds. There are six optimal cuts in all, with three of them being the most popular across the world.

James Allen has four diamond cuts to choose from. Two of these four are perfect cuts. Ideal cut diamonds reflect practically all light and are one of the most sought-after cuts in the industry.

The ideal cut, also known as a good cut , has near-perfect cut proportions and precise facet angles. Ideal cut diamonds’ brightness and fire are seldom overlooked. The James Allen Ideal cut diamonds’ flawlessly symmetrical facets transmit light to the eyes.

Each pavilion of an excellent cut diamond receives a tremendous quantity of light, which is reflected through the table and crown. The diamond’s brightness and fire are enhanced as a result.

Furthermore, the GIA and AGS laboratories assess perfect cut diamonds. Unlike the True Hearts, which have a Triple zero on AGS and an outstanding cut status on GIA certifications, the True Hearts have a Triple zero on AGS and an excellent cut status on GIA certifications. Despite being the most costly diamonds, they lack official certificates, but for most of us, this isn’t a deal-breaker.

Price and Value of True Heart vs. Ideal Cut

Both diamonds, without a doubt, provide superb value for money. You’ll have to pay a premium for diamonds that are of the highest quality. The better the cut, the more expensive it is.

The most significant characteristic of a diamond is its cut, which makes you want to spend more money. But you still worry if it’s worth it in the back of your mind.

Which One Should You Buy?

So here’s what I’d recommend. There’s no reason why you shouldn’t get the rarest diamond cuts if you have the money.

Ideal cut diamonds have a superior overall appearance than True Heart diamonds, and vice versa. When selecting a diamond, consider not just the dimensions but also the cut, clarity, and overall beauty.

If the ideal cut appeals to you more than the actual heart, go for it. James Allen’s True Hearts are certainly pricey. As the caratage grows, the price soars to new heights. But the fact that they are the rarest of the rare diamonds in the world is too much to bear. As a result, that will be a very rewarding investment.


Scroll to Top
Secured By miniOrange