Blue Nile Vs Brilliant Earth : Which Is Better? (2023 Comparison)

Looking to know who’s better between Blue Nile Vs Brilliant Earth?

You’re in the right place!

This is our comparison of the Blue Nile Vs Brilliant Earth.

In this article, I have reviewed both brands in-depth and will fully explain to you which one is better.

Let’s get started with an in-depth look at what sets these brands apart.

1) History

Blue Nile

Founded by Mark Vadon in 1999, Blue Nile was created with the goal of providing customers with high-quality diamonds at competitive prices, while also promoting transparency and ethical practices throughout the diamond industry.

See, Mark had a negative experience trying to buy a diamond engagement ring for himself and he was determined to change that for others. He set out to create an online retailer that would make it easier for customers to buy diamonds and fine jewelry, while also providing them with information and resources to help them make informed decisions.

And that’s exactly what Blue Nile does. They work with a network of trusted diamond suppliers and vendors to provide a wide variety of high-quality, ethically-sourced diamonds. Plus, they use a proprietary algorithm to match customers with the best diamonds based on their preferences and budget.

But that’s not all, fam. Blue Nile is also committed to promoting transparency and ethical practices throughout the diamond industry. They provide detailed information about each diamond, including its carat weight, cut, color, and clarity, as well as information about the mine of origin and the conditions under which it was mined.

In short, Blue Nile was one of the first online diamond retailers and it’s had a huge impact on the diamond industry by making the purchase of diamond engagement rings more easy and accessible to customers, while also promoting transparency and ethical practices throughout the diamond industry. If you’re in the market for a diamond engagement ring, Blue Nile should definitely be at the top of your list.

Brilliant Earth

Since 2005, Brilliant Earth has been shaking up the jewelry industry with its ethically-minded approach. Their focus is on using recycled precious metals, ethically-sourced diamonds and gemstones, and offering transparent and traceable sourcing practices. 

Brilliant Earth’s commitment to social and environmental responsibility has made them a leader in the industry and they have a reputation for being a trusted and reliable source of ethically-sourced jewelry. They have a wide range of products including engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry.

2) Website Navigation

Blue Nile

Their website is clean, sleek, and easy to navigate. The main navigation menu at the top of the page is simple and straightforward, with links to different sections of the site like engagement rings, wedding rings, and loose diamonds. They also have a search bar on the top right corner of the website, making it super easy to find exactly what you’re looking for.

But what really sets Blue Nile apart is their “Education” section. This section is packed with detailed information on diamonds, engagement rings, and other fine jewelry. It’s perfect for those who want to learn more about the industry before making a big purchase. Plus, the checkout process is simple and secure, and customer service is easily accessible through a chat feature, email, or phone.

Brilliant Earth

Their website is sleek and modern, making it easy to navigate and find exactly what you’re looking for. They’re all about ethically-sourced diamonds, so you can feel good about your purchase. 

One of the standout features of Brilliant Earth’s website is its “Create Your Own” section, where you can design your own engagement ring with its easy-to-use tool. It’s a fun and unique way to shop for a ring, and it’s something you won’t find on other diamond retailers’ sites.

The filters on Brilliant Earth’s site are also top-notch. You can filter by diamond shape, carat weight, price, and more to make your search even more specific. And, if you’re looking for a specific type of diamond, like a cushion cut or a rose cut, they’ve got you covered.

Winner: Blue Nile is the clear winner here.

3) Quality

Blue Nile

If you’re looking for the perfect diamond, Blue Nile has you covered. As one of the leading diamond retailers, their selection of diamonds is unparalleled and their commitment to customer satisfaction is second to none. 

From their extensive selection of certified diamonds to their detailed online education section, Blue Nile makes it easy for customers to make the best decision for their diamond purchase. They have a wide variety of diamonds to choose from in terms of carat weight, cut, color, and clarity, as well as information about the mine of origin and the conditions under which it was mined. 

For those who are nervous about making a long-term investment, Blue Nile provides a 100% satisfaction guarantee and a 30-day return policy, which gives customers the peace of mind they need. They also have a dedicated customer service team that is available to answer any questions you may have.

 When it comes to diamonds, Blue Nile is the ultimate destination for those looking for quality and assurance. Their commitment to providing customers with the best possible experience is evident in every aspect of their business, from their selection of diamonds to their customer service team.

Brilliant Earth

I’ve had the opportunity to check out Brilliant Earth’s engagement rings in person and let me tell you, the craftsmanship is absolutely stunning. From the prongs holding the diamonds in place to the smooth finish on the band, every detail is flawless.

But it’s not just about the aesthetics – they’re also committed to ethically sourcing their diamonds and using recycled precious metals for their jewelry.

One of the things that really impressed me was the 360-degree view feature on their website. It allows you to take a closer look at the ring from all angles before you commit to buying it. This feature makes it easy to envision the ring on your finger, and it’s a huge plus for online shoppers.

But what sets Brilliant Earth apart from other jewelry companies is their commitment to transparency. They use only conflict-free diamonds and provide detailed information on the origin and quality of each diamond on their website. This level of transparency is something that’s hard to come by in the industry, and it’s something that I appreciate as a consumer.

Another thing that I love about Brilliant Earth is that they also have a wide selection of lab-created diamonds. These diamonds are ethically sourced, and they’re a great choice for those who want to make a more sustainable purchase.

Winner: Based on quality Brilliant Earth is truly on another level.

4) Store Location

Blue Nile

I’ve been closely following the rise of online diamond and fine jewelry retailers for years. One of the biggest names in the business is Blue Nile, an online diamond and fine jewelry retailer that operates entirely through its website. 

What immediately stands out about Blue Nile is the sheer variety of high-quality diamonds and fine jewelry that they offer. Whether you’re looking for an engagement ring, a wedding band, or some other kind of jewelry, Blue Nile has something for you. And the best part is that their prices are incredibly competitive, making them one of the most affordable options out there.

 But what really makes the Blue Nile stand out is their commitment to customer service. They have a manufacturing facility in New York City where they create a variety of custom and designer jewelry pieces, as well as a team of experts available to help customers with their purchases. They also offer virtual consultations for those who want to shop remotely and make sure that their customers are happy with their purchases. 

In the end, Blue Nile is a great option for anyone looking for high-quality diamonds and fine jewelry at an affordable price. Their commitment to customer service, combined with their wide selection of products, makes them a top choice for online jewelry shopping.

Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth is a brand that really stands out to me. Not only do they have an impressive online presence, with a user-friendly website and a unique “Create Your Own” feature, but they also offer the added convenience of physical retail locations.

Their flagship store is located in San Francisco, but they also have additional locations in New York City, Chicago, Los Angeles, and even a showroom in London, UK.

This means that not only can you preview their rings online and customize your own with their online ring builder, but you also have the option to see the rings in person and get a true feel for the quality and craftsmanship.

In my opinion, this level of convenience and personal touch is what sets Brilliant Earth apart from other diamond and engagement ring retailers. They understand that purchasing a ring is a big decision, and they go above and beyond to make the process as easy and enjoyable as possible.

Winner: Brilliant Earth is the winner.

5) Pricing

Blue Nile

If you’re in the market for diamond and fine jewelry, Blue Nile is the perfect place to start your search. With engagement rings starting at around $500 and going up to tens of thousands of dollars for higher-quality diamonds, they offer something for everyone’s budget and style.

 One of the great things about Blue Nile is its commitment to transparency and providing detailed information about each diamond. They provide carat weight, cut, color, and clarity information, as well as a description of the mine of origin and the conditions under which it was mined. This helps customers make educated decisions about the diamond they choose. 

If you want to get even more creative, you can use Blue Nile’s “Build Your Own Ring” option, which allows you to customize the ring to your preferences and budget. You can choose the metal, stones, and style of the ring, giving you complete control of the design. 

On top of all this, Blue Nile also offers a variety of payment options, including financing, to make it more affordable for customers to purchase their products. So no matter what your budget is, you can find something that suits your needs and budget.

Brilliant Earth

When it comes to engagement rings, you want to find something that’s beautiful, ethically sourced, and fits your budget. And that’s exactly what you’ll find with Brilliant Earth.

One of the things that set Brilliant Earth apart is its wide range of pricing options. Whether you’re working with a tight budget or you’re looking to splurge, they’ve got something that will work for you.

For example, if you’re looking for an affordable option, you can snag a 0.22-carat diamond ring set in 14k gold for just $790. But if you’re looking for something that’s truly breathtaking, take a look at their 2-carat diamond ring set in platinum, featuring 20 diamonds in SI clarity, retailing for a cool $10,000.

But here’s the thing: no matter what your budget is, you can be sure that each ring is ethically sourced and certified to be conflict-free. Brilliant Earth is all about sustainability and making sure that your purchase has a positive impact on the world. And that’s something you can feel good about.

Winner: Blue Nile would be the winner on pricing.

6) Shipping

Blue Nile

Blue Nile is the perfect destination for anyone shopping for fine jewelry. They offer free shipping on all orders within the United States and Canada, with some orders arriving as quickly as 2-5 business days. They use a variety of shipping carriers, such as FedEx, UPS, and DHL, and provide customers with tracking information, so you can always stay up to date on the progress of your package. 

If you need your order to arrive sooner, Blue Nile also offers expedited shipping for an additional fee. They even offer international shipping, so you can get that piece of jewelry you’ve been eyeing no matter where you are. And if you’re lucky enough to live near one of their manufacturing facilities in New York City, you can take advantage of their in-store pickup option. 

Overall, Blue Nile is a great place to find and purchase fine jewelry with the convenience of having it shipped to your door with free shipping. And with their expedited and international shipping options, you’ll never have to wait too long for your order to arrive.

Brilliant Earth

When it comes to purchasing a piece of jewelry, the last thing you want to worry about is how it will arrive or if it will arrive on time. That’s why I highly recommend Brilliant Earth.

Brilliant Earth is a company that takes the shipping and delivery process seriously. They offer free shipping on all orders, which is always a plus. And with delivery times typically ranging from 3-7 business days, you won’t have to wait long to receive your new piece of jewelry.

But the best part? Every order is insured and tracked for your peace of mind. I’ve had my fair share of experience with online shopping, and let me tell you, tracking is everything. Knowing that your order is insured and can be tracked gives me a sense of security and peace of mind.

Another thing I love about Brilliant Earth is its packaging. The items come in a secure package with a tamper-proof seal, so you know that your purchase has not been tampered with and is in perfect condition.

For international customers, I do want to mention that you may be subject to extra taxes, customs, or other charges, so make sure to check with local regulations before ordering. But other than that, Brilliant Earth is a company that delivers on time and in perfect condition.

Winner: Brilliant Earth wins.

7) Return Policy

Blue Nile

Blue Nile is a great place to shop for jewelry, but what if you need to return something? Here’s what you need to know about Blue Nile’s returns policy.

 In order to initiate a return, customers must contact Blue Nile’s customer service team to obtain a return authorization number. It’s important that the item is returned in its original condition, with all original packaging and documentation intact – any item that has been altered, or is missing parts or documentation, won’t be accepted for return. 

Custom-made or special orders are non-refundable, and customers are responsible for the return shipping costs – so make sure to keep track of the tracking number when you ship your return. Shipping and handling fees are also non-refundable.

 On the plus side, Blue Nile offers a free resizing service for engagement and wedding rings within 60 days of purchase. Plus, they have a lifetime warranty for all of their engagement and wedding rings, so you’re covered if anything ever happens to your purchase. 

So, if you’re looking to return something at Blue Nile, make sure you have all the original packaging and documentation, and contact their customer service team to get a return authorization number.

Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth is a force to be reckoned with. They have a wide range of high-quality products that are ethically sourced, a user-friendly website, and excellent customer support.

But what really sets them apart from the competition is their return and exchange policy. If you’re not satisfied with your purchase, you can return or exchange any item within 30 days of delivery for a full refund. And the best part? They’ll even provide you with a free, pre-paid return label so you don’t have to worry about covering the cost of postage.

The process of returning or exchanging an item is also a breeze. All you have to do is reach out to Brilliant Earth’s customer service team, and they’ll walk you through the process.

Just keep in mind that all items must be undamaged, unworn, and in their original condition to be eligible for a return or exchange. Also, after the 30-day period has passed, any item is considered a final sale. Additionally, all custom orders, including custom-set diamonds, custom-made rings, and personalized engravings, are also a final sale.

Winner: Brilliant Earth wins.

8) Customer Support

Blue Nile

I recently had the pleasure of trying out Blue Nile, an online jewelry retailer that offers a comprehensive selection of diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry. Every piece is stunning, and I was immediately impressed by the detailed information and diamond grading reports that come with each item.

Plus, Blue Nile’s return policy and lifetime warranty are unbeatable, so I know that if I make a purchase, I’m totally covered. 

But the thing that really sold me on Blue Nile is the virtual try-on service. All you have to do is upload a photo of your hand and the website will show you what the ring would look like on your finger, so you don’t have to worry about making a purchase and then finding out it doesn’t fit. This is such a great feature and makes it super easy to find the perfect ring. 

Overall, I had a great experience with Blue Nile and I highly recommend them to anyone looking for quality jewelry. The selection is top-notch, the customer service is excellent, and the virtual try-on service is a great way to make sure your purchase is perfect.

Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth truly stands out when it comes to customer service.

When you’re making a purchase as important as an engagement ring, customer service is key. You want to work with a company that truly cares about your satisfaction and will go above and beyond to make sure you’re happy with your purchase. And that’s exactly what Brilliant Earth does.

Their team of knowledgeable professionals is available to assist you with any questions or concerns you may have. They have extended hours of availability, reachable by phone from 8 am to 7 pm ET, Monday through Saturday, and by email, making them one of the most customer-friendly companies in the market.

Winner: Brilliant Earth wins this round. It offers slightly longer hours of availability

9) Customer Reviews Online

Blue Nile

If you’re looking for a reliable and trustworthy jewelry company, Blue Nile is the one to go with. Their customer reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with many customers praising their quality, service, and overall experience. Additionally, their website is free of any complaints related to delays in delivery, making them a reliable choice for those wanting to purchase jewelry without worry.

In this regard, Blue Nile surpasses Brilliant Earth, which has been known to have delays in delivering goods. 

What’s more, is that the reviews for Blue Nile don’t look spammy, unlike those of Brilliant Earth. This is essential, as it shows that Blue Nile is genuinely dedicated to providing quality service and products to their customers. 

When it comes to buying jewelry, it’s important to consider the company’s reputation, customer reviews, and delivery times. Blue Nile is the clear winner in this regard, as they have proven to be a reliable and trustworthy jewelry company, with overwhelmingly positive reviews and no complaints related to delivery delays.

Brilliant Earth

Now, Brilliant Earth is a little different. They’re all about ethically-sourced and eco-friendly diamonds. And from what I can see, they’re doing a pretty damn good job. They’ve got a 4.7-star rating on Wedding Wire, which is still pretty damn good.

And most customers seem to be very satisfied with the diamonds and services they’ve received from Brilliant Earth. A lot of customers are praising the company for its commitment to ethical sourcing and environmentally friendly practices.

And some customers have even said that the customer service is exceptional, with the staff being very helpful in finding the perfect ring for them.

So, if you’re looking for an environmentally friendly diamond ring and a company that is committed to ethical sourcing, Brilliant Earth is definitely worth checking out.

Winner: Blue Nile wins this round.

10) Warranty

Blue Nile

I am always on the lookout for products and services that provide customers with a sense of security and peace of mind. And when it comes to fine jewelry, there is no better option than Blue Nile’s warranty. 

The warranty covers any defects in materials or workmanship for a period of one year from the date of purchase, giving customers a year’s worth of protection from any flaws in the jewelry. But that’s not all – Blue Nile also offers a lifetime warranty on their engagement rings, which covers any repairs and resizing needed due to normal wear.

This provides customers with the assurance that their ring can be taken care of if needed, without having to worry about the cost of repairs. 

In addition to the repair coverage, Blue Nile also provides customers with free prong tightening, re-polishing, rhodium plating, and cleaning services. This is a great bonus as it ensures that customers can keep their jewelry looking its best for years to come. 

Overall, Blue Nile’s warranty is an excellent value and provides customers with the peace of mind they need when investing in fine jewelry. With its comprehensive coverage and free services, it’s no wonder why so many customers choose

Brilliant Earth

This company is committed to providing its customers with high-quality, ethically-sourced diamonds that will stand the test of time. They understand the importance of a lifetime investment and that’s why they provide a warranty to ensure that you’re happy with your purchase now and in the future.

Their warranty covers any manufacturing defects on the ring, and they will repair or replace the ring at no charge to you. They also cover any loss of accent diamonds weighing 0.15 carats or less that occur due to normal wear and tear.

However, this warranty doesn’t cover loss or damage caused by abuse, misuse, or unauthorized repair. It’s also worth mentioning that their warranty doesn’t cover the center diamond or gemstone, as they don’t manufacture these themselves.

But, if you need any repairs, just contact their customer service and they will be happy to help you, and the fees will be assessed according to the repair needs as determined by their jewelers.

Winner: Blue Nile wins this round.

Overall Winner

Brilliant Earth is definitely at the top of my list.

One of the things that set Brilliant Earth apart is its commitment to ethical sourcing. They are dedicated to ensuring that their diamonds are mined in a responsible and sustainable way, and they even have a traceability program that allows customers to track the origin of their diamonds.

But it’s not just their ethics that make Brilliant Earth stand out. They also have an incredibly user-friendly website that makes it easy to find the perfect ring. Plus, their customer support team is always available to answer any questions you may have.

And let’s not forget about the quality of their products. Brilliant Earth’s diamonds are absolutely stunning, and their engagement rings are designed to showcase the beauty of the stone. They even have a range of videos on their website that allow you to get a closer look at their products.

In short, Brilliant Earth is dominating the diamond and engagement ring market for a reason. They offer high-quality products that are ethically sourced, and their website and customer support are top-notch. If you’re in the market for a diamond ring, I highly recommend checking out Brilliant Earth.

Related:

Blue Nile Vs Costco

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top