Blue Nile Resizing Policy (2024 Explained)

Wondering if Blue Nile’s resizing policy is any good?

Coming from one of our other reviews of Bile Nile diamonds and want to learn more?

I took the initiative to gather authentic feedback from real customers who have experienced Blue Nile’s customer service firsthand during their purchases. Drawing from their valuable insights, I have meticulously compiled a comprehensive list of Blue Nile Customer Service details.

By reading this article, you can rest assured that you’ll be equipped with all the necessary information to make an informed decision that aligns perfectly with your needs. Bid farewell to uncertainty and guesswork – I’ve got you covered with all you need to know about Blue Nile’s resizing policy.

Let’s get started!

Blue Nile Resizing Policy

Blue Nile provides a complimentary ring resizing service for all purchased rings within the first year. Additionally, they offer a 30-day exchange policy, allowing customers to exchange their ring for a different one if they wish to do so, for any reason.

Can any ring be resized by Blue Nile?

While Blue Nile offers free resizing for rings, it’s important to note that there are limitations to which rings can undergo this service. Several reasons contribute to why some rings cannot be resized, and these reasons include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. Diamond and Gemstone Eternity Rings: Rings with precious stones set all around the band, such as diamond and gemstone eternity rings, cannot be resized easily. The intricate setting and continuous arrangement of stones make resizing impractical without potentially compromising the design and structural integrity of the ring.
2. Milgrain or Ornate Bands: Rings with delicate milgrain detailing or ornate patterns cannot be resized without affecting the intricate design. Resizing such rings may disrupt the pattern, resulting in an undesirable appearance.
3. Certain Silver Rings: Some silver rings may not be resizable due to the nature of the metal. Resizing silver rings can lead to issues like metal weakening or damage, making it unfeasible to alter their size.
4. Tungsten Rings: Tungsten is a very hard and durable metal, which makes resizing difficult. The properties of tungsten make it challenging to work with for resizing purposes.

To ensure transparency and provide customers with clear information, Blue Nile makes it easy to understand which rings cannot be resized. They include this information on the product page of each ring that falls under the category of non-resizable. By providing this guidance upfront, customers can make informed decisions when selecting their preferred rings.

Ring Resizing Process

The Blue Nile resizing process is designed to be simple and hassle-free:

1. Contact Blue Nile Customer Service: Reach out to Blue Nile’s customer service either by calling 1-800-425-022 or using the live chat feature on their website. Inform them that you need to return the ring for resizing.
2. Receive Shipping Label: The Blue Nile customer service team will promptly email you a free, insured shipping label to facilitate the return process.
3. Include Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) Number: Make sure to clearly indicate the Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) number on the outside of the shipping box. This helps ensure that your package is correctly processed upon arrival.
4. Discreet Packaging: To enhance security during transit, avoid mentioning “Blue Nile” or any other branding on the exterior of the box. This precaution minimizes the risk of theft or tampering.

By following these straightforward steps, you can initiate the resizing process with ease, ensuring that your ring is handled safely and efficiently. Blue Nile’s customer service team is ready to assist you throughout the entire process, ensuring your satisfaction with their resizing service.

How much time does Blue Nile take to resize a ring?

The duration for resizing a ring with Blue Nile varies based on several factors, including the number of resizing requests, jeweler availability, and the specific modifications required. Typically, Blue Nile can resize and ship the ring back within 12 to 14 days after receiving it. However, in some cases, the process may take a month or even longer.

For example, during peak wedding seasons like June or July, a surge in resizing requests can lead to delays. Nevertheless, Blue Nile provides a convenient tracking feature on their official website’s Services page, allowing customers to monitor the progress of their resize request and the return status of their ring. This transparency helps customers stay informed about the timeline of their resizing order.

How much does Blue Nile charge for resizing a ring?

Blue Nile offers complimentary resizing services for most engagement rings and diamond bands within the first year of purchase. However, resizing for different rings or after the first year does come at a cost. The fee varies depending on factors such as the type of ring, the setting, the material used, and the extent of size adjustment required for resizing.

To obtain an estimate of the resizing cost, customers can reach out to Blue Nile’s customer support agents. These experts are well-informed about their products, return policies, and resizing procedures. They can provide customers with a rough quote based on specific details, including the type of ring, the setting style, the material of the ring, and the extent of resizing needed.

By seeking assistance from Blue Nile’s customer support, customers can have a better understanding of the resizing process and the associated costs before proceeding with their resizing requests. This transparency and support from Blue Nile’s expert team ensure a smooth and informed resizing experience for customers.

Get the ring size right the first time

Blue Nile strives to make the process of avoiding ring resizing as easy as possible. They provide helpful tips on how to accurately measure your ring finger to ensure a perfect fit. Additionally, they offer two different options for ring sizers to assist customers in finding their ideal ring size.

Free Blue Nile Plastic Ring Sizer

Blue Nile’s plastic ring sizer is designed for effortless usability. To determine the correct ring size, you simply need to follow these easy steps:

1. Place the Ring Sizer on Your Finger: Gently slide your finger into the plastic ring sizer and move it slowly until you find a comfortable fit. Ensure that the sizer is snug enough not to fall off your finger but still easy to remove over the knuckle.
2. Note the Size: Once you have found the perfect fit, take note of the size indicated by the plastic ring sizer.

Using this user-friendly tool, you can accurately determine your ring size in a straightforward manner. By finding the right size with the plastic ring sizer, you can confidently select the ideal ring from Blue Nile without the need for resizing.

Ring Size Chart & Printable Guide

If you prefer a quicker option without waiting for the plastic ring sizer to be delivered, Blue Nile offers a printable ring size chart and guide on their website for free. Here’s how you can use it:

1. Print the Ring Size Chart: Download and print the Blue Nile ring size chart from their website. Ensure that you set the page scaling to 100% to maintain accuracy.
2. Place Your Old Ring: Take a ring that currently fits you well and place it over the circles provided on the right side of the guide.
3. Match the Inside of the Ring: Align your old ring with the circles and identify the one that best matches the inside diameter of your old ring.
4. Order the Larger Size: If your ring size falls between two circles on the chart, it is recommended to choose the larger size. This ensures a comfortable fit.
5. Consider Sizing Up: If you are unsure about your exact ring size, it is advisable to go slightly larger as rings can be resized down more easily than they can be resized up.

By using this printable ring size chart and guide, you can get a good estimate of your ring size without the need for professional assistance or waiting for a physical ring sizer.

Should you get your ring resized with Blue Nile?

While Blue Nile provides one year of complimentary resizing for most engagement rings and wedding bands, additional resizing requests beyond the first year will incur a cost. Some may consider seeking resizing services from a local jeweler to avoid potential expenses. However, it’s important to note that any resizing done outside of Blue Nile will void the Lifetime Manufacturer’s warranty.

Blue Nile advises against resizing to maintain the ring’s overall quality and balance. They offer various resources to help customers find their correct ring size. If needed, Blue Nile does provide free resizing within the first year. Opting for resizing with Blue Nile ensures adherence to strict quality standards, and it safeguards the manufacturer’s warranty, eliminating the risk of voiding it.